Blog/Buying leads

How to test a lead vendor with 50 leads

Every lead company sounds good on the phone. The only way to know is to buy some leads and work them properly. Done carelessly, a test tells you nothing and costs you a month. Done well, 50 leads is enough to make a decision.

Before you buy: get five things in writing

These take one email to settle and save a lot of arguing later.

  • Exclusive or shared. If shared, with how many buyers. "Semi-exclusive" means shared.
  • Where the leads come from. Their own ads and pages, or bought from someone else? Fresh, or collected weeks ago?
  • What counts as a bad lead, and what happens when you get one. Credit, replacement, or nothing?
  • How long you have to report it. Some vendors give you 48 hours, which is not enough to make three call attempts.
  • How you stop. A test with a three-month contract attached isn't a test.

If a vendor won't answer these plainly, you've learned what you needed to know without spending anything.

Set the test up so it's fair

Keep the area tight. Pick the ZIP codes where you already close well. If the leads don't work there, they won't work anywhere.

Pick a normal month. Not the week your best salesperson is on vacation, and not the slowest stretch of your year.

Work them like you mean it. Call within minutes, try at least three times over two days, send a text. If you test with half an effort you'll get half a result and blame the leads.

What to write down for every lead

One line per lead, filled in as you go:

  • When it arrived and when you first called
  • Whether you reached the homeowner
  • Whether the details were right: owner, correct address, real project
  • Whether an estimate was booked
  • Whether it sold, and for how much

Also note what people say when you reach them. "Who is this?" and "I never asked for that" are warning signs about how the lead was generated. "Oh good, thanks for calling" is what a real request sounds like.

Reading the results

Fifty leads won't give you a precise close rate. Three sales and five sales are the same result at that size. What 50 leads will tell you reliably is the top of the funnel.

Contact rate. If you called quickly and reached fewer than a third, something is wrong with the source.

Accuracy. How many were renters, wrong numbers or outside your area? A few is normal. A fifth of the batch isn't.

Intent. Of the people you reached, how many remembered asking and wanted to talk about a real project?

If those three look healthy, the leads are sound and the rest depends on your sales process. Order a larger batch and keep tracking. If they look poor, stop. More volume from a bad source won't fix it.

Test the vendor, too

Report your bad leads and watch what happens. Do they replace them without a fight? Do they answer when you ask why three leads in a row came from the same street? How a vendor behaves over $200 of credits is how they'll behave over $20,000.

Keep reading

Exclusive vs. shared leads: the math most contractors skip

Shared leads look cheaper until you count how many of them you actually reach. Here is how to compare the two on cost per sale.

Read the article · 3 min

Why cost per lead is the wrong number to watch

Cost per lead is easy to compare and easy to get fooled by. The four numbers a contractor should track instead, and how to work them out.

Read the article · 2 min

How to buy solar leads: a practical guide for installers

Where solar leads come from, what the different types cost you in practice, the questions to ask before you buy, and how to start without wasting a month's budget.

Read the article · 4 min