Blog/Buying leads
Why cost per lead is the wrong number to watch
Ask a contractor how their lead buying is going and you'll usually get a price. "We're paying forty-five a lead." It's the number on the invoice, so it's the number people remember.
It's also the least useful number in the whole chain. A $30 lead can be a terrible deal and a $90 lead can be a great one. You can't tell which until you follow them further down.
The four numbers that matter
Between paying for a lead and banking a deposit, four things happen. Each one loses some leads along the way.
- Contact rate. Of the leads you bought, how many did you actually speak to?
- Appointment rate. Of those conversations, how many turned into an estimate or site visit?
- Close rate. Of those estimates, how many signed?
- Average job value. What is a signed job worth to you?
Multiply the first three and you get the share of leads that become customers. Divide the lead price by that share and you get your cost per sale.
A worked example
Say you buy 100 leads at $50. That's $5,000.
You reach 55 of them. Twenty-two book an estimate. You sign seven. Seven sales from 100 leads means each sale cost about $714 in leads.
If your average job brings in $12,000 and you keep 30% after labor and materials, that's $3,600 of margin per job. Spending $714 to earn $3,600 is a good trade. If your average job is a $900 repair, it isn't.
Same lead, same price, opposite answer. That's why the price alone tells you nothing.
Where cheap leads usually fall down
Low prices tend to come from one of three places: the lead was sold to several companies, the homeowner wasn't really qualified, or the lead is old. All three show up as a poor contact rate or a poor appointment rate.
A lead that costs half as much but converts a third as often is more expensive. You only see that if you track the steps.
Which step is yours to fix
This is the useful part of breaking it down. Each number points at a different problem.
A low contact rate is usually about speed, or about lead quality: wrong numbers, people who never asked for a call. Compare how fast you called against how many you reached. If you were fast and still couldn't reach people, look hard at the source.
A low appointment rate with a healthy contact rate means the conversations aren't landing. Either the homeowners weren't serious, or the first call needs work.
A low close rate after plenty of estimates is a sales or pricing question. No lead vendor can fix that for you, and a good one will say so.
Keep it simple enough to maintain
You don't need software for this. A spreadsheet with one row per lead and five columns works: date, source, reached (yes or no), estimate (yes or no), sold (amount). Fill it in every Friday.
After a month you'll be able to say what a sale costs you from each source. That's the only comparison worth making, and very few of your competitors bother to make it.
If you'd like to try the arithmetic with your own figures, our cost-per-sale calculator does it in a few seconds.
Keep reading
Exclusive vs. shared leads: the math most contractors skip
Shared leads look cheaper until you count how many of them you actually reach. Here is how to compare the two on cost per sale.
Read the article · 3 minBuying leadsHow to test a lead vendor with 50 leads
A fair way to try a new lead source before you commit real budget: what to agree up front, what to track, and when to walk away.
Read the article · 2 minSolar leadsHow to buy solar leads: a practical guide for installers
Where solar leads come from, what the different types cost you in practice, the questions to ask before you buy, and how to start without wasting a month's budget.
Read the article · 4 min