Blog/Buying leads
Exclusive vs. shared leads: the math most contractors skip
A shared lead at $20 looks like a bargain next to an exclusive one at $60. Three for the price of one. Most contractors stop the comparison there, and that's where it goes wrong.
The price of a lead tells you very little. What you pay for a signed job tells you everything, and the two numbers can point in opposite directions.
What "shared" means in practice
When a homeowner fills in a form on a marketplace, the same request is sold to several companies, often three to five and sometimes more. All of them get it at the same moment. All of them call.
Think about that from the homeowner's side. They asked one question on one website. Ten minutes later their phone has rung four times from numbers they don't recognize. By the third call they've stopped picking up. If you were fourth, you paid for a lead you will never speak to.
So a shared lead is really a race. The first company to reach the homeowner has a real conversation. Everyone else is leaving voicemails.
Run the numbers on your own business
Take 100 leads of each kind and follow them to the end. The figures below are an example. Swap in your own.
Shared, $20 each. You spend $2,000. Say you reach 30 of them, because you're quick but not always first. Ten agree to an estimate. You close three. Each sale cost you about $667 in leads.
Exclusive, $60 each. You spend $6,000. Nobody else is calling, so you reach 60. Twenty-five agree to an estimate. You close eight. Each sale cost you $750.
On those numbers shared wins by a little. Now change one thing: your office is busy and it takes an hour to call back instead of five minutes. On shared leads your contact rate collapses, because someone else got there first. On exclusive leads it drops too, but far less. Suddenly the cheap lead is the expensive one.
That's the real difference. Shared leads punish you hard for being slow. Exclusive leads forgive more.
The costs that don't show on the invoice
Lead price isn't your only cost. Somebody has to make the calls. If your rep dials 100 shared leads to hold 30 conversations, that's 70 calls that produced nothing, plus the voicemails and texts that followed.
There's also price pressure. A homeowner who has heard from four contractors is comparing four quotes. You'll be asked to match the lowest. A homeowner who has only heard from you is deciding whether to do the project, which is a much better conversation to be in.
When shared leads make sense
They aren't always the wrong choice. If you have someone whose only job is to call new leads within a minute or two, all day, you can win the race often enough to make the low price pay. Large companies with call centers do exactly this.
If the person calling leads is also the person running jobs, answering the office phone and ordering materials, you will lose that race most days. In that case you're paying for leads that other people close.
How to decide
Don't take anyone's word for it, including ours. Buy a small batch of each kind in the same area during the same weeks. Track four numbers for each: leads bought, homeowners reached, estimates given, jobs signed. Divide what you spent by jobs signed.
The lower number wins. It usually takes about a month to see it clearly.
Keep reading
Why cost per lead is the wrong number to watch
Cost per lead is easy to compare and easy to get fooled by. The four numbers a contractor should track instead, and how to work them out.
Read the article · 2 minBuying leadsHow to test a lead vendor with 50 leads
A fair way to try a new lead source before you commit real budget: what to agree up front, what to track, and when to walk away.
Read the article · 2 minSolar leadsHow to buy solar leads: a practical guide for installers
Where solar leads come from, what the different types cost you in practice, the questions to ask before you buy, and how to start without wasting a month's budget.
Read the article · 4 min